All articlesAssessment

Assessment Without Tears: Feedback That Grows Writers

Rowena Tam 3/18/2026Goodschool · Issue 88

Feedback that students actually use: practical marking strategies that reduce teacher workload and grow confident writers.

Assessment as feedback, not verdict

In Hong Kong's exam-heavy culture, students experience assessment as judgement. English teachers can rebalance this by making feedback the centre of assessment practice: every piece of marked work should tell the student one thing to keep and one thing to change.

Two stars and a wish

The classic formula still works. Two genuine strengths, one focused improvement point. Resist the urge to correct every error — a page of red ink teaches students that mistakes are shameful, not informative.

Making marking loadable

  1. Mark in class. Live marking during writing tasks gives instant feedback and takes nothing home.
  2. Use codes, not comments. Teach students your marking codes in September; by October they self-correct.
  3. Peer feedback with sentence stems. "The strongest part of your writing is..." models useful critique and halves your workload.

The growth mindset, concretely

Don't tell students "you can improve" — show them the previous draft next to the current one. Progress made visible is the most powerful motivator in the English classroom.